Wiki Article "gay Men In The Singapore Armed Forces"

[groyn88]

I have written a wiki article entitled, "Gay men in the Singapore Armed Forces".

Could you kindly read it and comment on its accuracy or deficiencies?

Thanks!

http://sporelgbtpedia.shoutwiki.com/wiki/Gay_men_in_the_Singapore_Armed_Forces

All male Singaporean citizens and non-first generation permanent residents, including homosexual, bisexual and male-at-birth transgender individuals, who have reached the age of 18 years are required to enroll for National Service under the Enlistment Act. They serve a 22- or 24-month period as Full Time National Servicemen (NSFs), either in the Singapore Armed Forces (SAF), Singapore Police Force (SPF), or the Singapore Civil Defence Force (SCDF).
The way gay and transgender servicemen are viewed and treated is largely dependent on the views of the military authorities who write the manpower directives which govern the management of these enlistees even though they are advised by external non-military psychiatrists.
Discrimination exists because these authorities still cling to the outdated concept that homosexuality is a psychiatric condition even though all medical textbooks and international psychiatric, psychological and sociological authorities jettisoned this mistaken notion in the last century and now regard homosexuality as part of the normal spectrum of human sexuality.

Medical examination

Part of the first step into National Service for all new recruits is the mandatory medical examination. This consists of the PULHHEEMS assessment (see main article: PULHHEEMS), followed by PES (Physical Employment Status) categorisation (see main article: PES). Both are performed at the Central Manpower Base (CMPB). PES grading determines the suitability of each serviceman in the various military vocations. For established servicemen and women, PES reassessment is a requirement for ongoing employment. Although a PULHHEEMS is carried out on new enlistees, it is not itself an entrance examination, the attributes of which depend on the branch of the military conducting the examination.
PES grading is carried out on recruits, and five-yearly after a serviceman or woman reaches the age of 30. After the age of 50, people in service are examined every two years. All generals in any branch of the military must be examined yearly. Furthermore, service personnel under the age of 30 are required to undergo PULHHEEMS in order to attend certain courses, whether occupational or promotional, and also if medically downgraded. A PULHHEEMS assessment is also carried out prior to leaving the armed forces, in part because many former servicemen remain as reservists.
The part of PULHHEEMS which concerns homosexual servicmen is the 'M' which stands for 'mental function'. Recruits are given a questionnaire about their medical history. One of the questions introduced in the late 2000s is about their sexual orientation. Once they declare their homosexuality in the form, the are referred to an external, non-military psychiatrist sitting in with the medical examination panel who will assess their emotional and mental health.

Category 302

Homosexual soldiers are classified under 'Category 302', a practice which gives rise to much of the discrimination they face during National Service.
Category 302 is a medical code given to personnel who are "homosexuals, transvestites, paedophiles, etc.", as stated in a confidential directive.
This code was derived from an outdated version of the ICD's (International Classification of Diseases) codes for mental disorders. The ICD is the World Health Organisation's (WHO) health care classification system which provides a system of diagnostic codes for classifying diseases for epidemiology, health management and clinical purposes. Singapore's medical establishment, including that of her military have adopted the ICD system to classify all diseases here.
The SAF's Category 302 bears exactly the same number as the now-defunct ICD-9's (ICD-9th revision, published in 1978) codes for psychosexual disorders. 'Code 302' in the ICD-9 was the code for 'sexual deviation'. At the time of the ICD-9's publication in 1978, homosexuality, together with zoophilia, paedophila and satyriasis, amongst others, was included under Code 302.
However, a landmark development was the removal of homosexuality from inclusion under Code 302 in the ICD-9 by the World Health Organisation in 1990. This was long overdue as the world's most renowned bible for psychiatric diagnosis, the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM), published by the American Psychiatric Association had removed homosexuality from its list of mental disorders in 1973.
The ICD is currently in its 10th revision (ICD-10, published in 1992) and its Chapter V, which deals with mental and behavioural disorders, has overhauled its predecessor's codes entirely - the number 302 is nowhere to be found.
Homosexual soldiers classified under Category 302 (popularly referred to as "cat 302" or simply "302") are further subdivided into those "with effeminate behaviour" and those "without effeminate behaviour" based on the arbitrary observations of the examining psychiatrist. The higher the perceived level of effeminacy, the lower the PES grading. One drawback of this arbitrary assignment is that some gay NSmen may fake effeminate mannerisms to obtain a lower PES status, which will in turn lead to less demanding physical training and exemption from staying in camp. Enlistees certified as transgender are assigned the lowest status of PES F and are not required to do National Service.
It is not clear why the SAF persists in using such an outdated classification of homosexuality in its assessment of the medical fitness of recruits. This refusal to jettison an archaic medical concept of homosexuality engenders discrimination because the military's grouping of homosexuality together with transvestism and paedophilia further reinforces the general public's misconception that it is abnormal.
It is therefore not surprising that "302" has become derogatory army slang for an effeminate soldier.
On the other hand, the SAF may also have the benevolent intention of protecting servicemen classified under Category 302 from emotional and physical abuse by their heterosexual colleagues. Indeed, some gay servicemen think that it is beneficial for them to be thus classified. Another advantage was the former exemption of even masculine Category 302 personnel from staying in camp and from combat training.
Since the mid-2000s, military psychiatrist have brought their concept of homosexuality more in line with that of their civilian counterparts, i.e. that homosexuality is part of the normal spectrum of human sexuality. This had led to the non-exemption of masculine gay NSmen from combat training and staying out of camp. However, will Category 302 still in place, homosexuals in the military are marked as different and potentially subject to discrimination.

Category 30-B

A less well known classification of psychological function is Category 30-B, a medical code given to servicemen "with effeminate behaviour not amounting to sexual disorders". These individuals are further subdivided into "mildly effeminate", "effeminate" and "severely effeminate". Presumably, this group only includes effeminate heterosexual men and not homosexuals, so there have historically been very few servicemen slapped with this label; hence, its relative obscurity.
However, since the late 2000s, this category was merged with the other sub-categories of 302.
Management[edit]

Self-declared or discovered servicemen are referred to the Psychological Medicine Branch of the Headquarters of Medical Services (HQMS) for a thorough psychiatric assessment which, prior to the late 2000s, involved their parents being called in for an interview.
They are medically downgraded to a Public Employment Status of C (PES C), regardless of their level of fitness, and put through modified Basic Military Training. On graduation, they are deployed in a vocation which has no security risks, posted to non-sensitive units and given a security status which restricts their access to classified documents. The reason for this is presumably the fear of the authorities that they will divulge military secrets if they are blackmailed about their sexual orientation. Critics of this policy point out that if Category 302 were scrapped, it would give rise to much less prejudice against gay servicemen so that they would no longer fear being blackmailed.
Formerly, Category 302 personnel were not allowed to stay overnight in-camp, nor were they required to perform night duties, but these restrictions have been relaxed. Effeminate homosexuals are also posted to a holding list upon completion of National Service and not required to do reservist training, whilst non-effeminate ones have undergo it in non-sensitive units.
Gay National Servicemen in popular culture[edit]

Movies

Army Daze
Purple Light

Videos

Individuals who have come out about their experiences as openly gay NSmen[edit]

Lim Chi-Sharn

Lim Chi-Sharn was the first Singaporean to come out about the declaration of his homosexuality to the Singapore Armed Forces and his experience of the medical procedure of being classified under Category 302. He wrote three seminal articles in Fridae in 2002, two of them jointly with his mother, author Christine Suchen-Lim, detailing these experiences.

Nicholas Deroose

Nicholas Deroose, originator of Singapore's first regular audio webcast, 'Queercast', recounted his coming out to his fellow National Servicemen in a chapter in the book, 'SQ21: Singapore Queers in the 21st Century'. Deroose's army experiences were also described briefly in Chapter 4, '"Oi, Recruit! Wake up your idea!"' of the book, 'Queer Singapore: Illiberal Citizenship and Mediated Cultures'.

Forum on gay men in National Service

On Saturday, 7 June 2014 at 7:30 pm, a forum organised by LGBT youth organisations, SGRainbow and The Purple Alliance, was held at the arts cafe, Artistry, along Jalan Pinang. It was entitled 'Every gay Singaporean son' and chaired by Nicholas Deroose. 4 young adult men shared their experiences and advice on serving National Service as gay individuals.

See also

PES
PULHHEEMS
Discrimination against homosexuals in Singapore

References

Fridae articles on serving National Service as an openly gay man, by Lim Chi-Sharn and his mother, Suchen Christine Lim:[1],[2],[3].
Blowing Wind discussions on being gay in the army:
Declaring 302 status:[4]
Is It Better To Declare Gay/302?:[5]
NS Specialist Declaring 302 During Service:[6]
Questions About Military/NS - Enlistment/Medical Checkup/ORD (Compiled):[7]
Chris K K Tan, Chapter 4, 'Oi, Recruit! Wake up your idea!' in the book, 'Queer Singapore: Illiberal Pragmatics and Mediated Cultures'[8],[9],[10].

Edited June 8, 2014 by groyn88

[Fe5000]

hey, your references questionable you know.

[keyboard]

Agree references has to be much much more substantial, you can't quote forums and term them as scientific proof.

 

Also,

"Discrimination exists because these authorities still cling to the outdated concept that homosexuality is a psychiatric condition even though all medical textbooks and international psychiatric, psychological and sociological authorities jettisoned this mistaken notion in the last century and now regard homosexuality as part of the normal spectrum of human sexuality."

 

Sounds very bias doesn't it. You should be building your case based on academic research, there are two sides of a coin. Provide a more researched wiki to be more convincing, good effort to write something about it.

[Cube3]

NS details seem quite thorough, though. ...If amendments required then be receptive to feedback and adjust on wiki accordingly lor! GREAT WORK! :clap: :clap: :clap:

[groyn88]

I have the following questions, the answers to which will be useful to include in the article:

1) What is the entire range of questions in the questionnaire handed to new recruits to fill out? Sexual orientation is just one of them. Do they ask recruits about their sexual history, personality, medical problems, etc., etc.? Does anyone have a hard copy of the questionnaire? In which year did they start giving out this questionnaire? When I was a recruit, I didn't recall ever being given a questionnaire to fill out. On which day after you enlist are you handed the questionnaire - is it on the very first day or later?

2) After you declare in the questionnaire that you're gay, where are you sent to for the first psychological assessment? To CMPB? To MMI at NUH? And who performs the assessment, a regular army psychiatrist or a civilian one? How many sessions of assessment are there in total?

3) If you declare your homosexuality after serving some time in NS, is the procedure exactly the same or different compared to for recruits? Where will you be assessed this time and by whom?

4) What is the name, number and content of the manpower directives which govern the management of gay and transgender recruits, servicemen and regulars?

5) When I was a recruit in the 1970s, HQMS was located at CMPB in Dempsey Road. I understand that HQMS has now been split into 3 more specialised departments, all located at Nee Soon Camp. What exactly do they do in relation to gay servicemen?

6) If you experience bullying or personal problems on account of your sexual orientation during NS, who is the best person to approach? Your OC? Where are the army counsellors located, do they even exist and how do you get referred to them? Can you get a referral to a civilian LGBT counselling organisation like Oogachaga?

7) What happens if you get caught having sex by a superior? Will they put you in the detention barracks or refer you to the police? Or will they just warn you? Is there any difference if you have sex in a private space like a toilet cubicle compared to in the open like during field camp? Do the NCOs and officers make a general announcement to the recruits not to have sex with their buddies?

Thanks!

Edited June 9, 2014 by groyn88

[Guest]

Is this article true that you hace to declare that you are gay when entering NS?

[Guest Guest]

On 06/03/2016 at 1:32 AM, Guest said:

Is this article true that you hace to declare that you are gay when entering NS?

 

I'm going to NS next year. Should I really need to declare that I'm gay?

[abang]

This is just a friend's experience.

He declared his 302 status during the 80s.  

It is NOT as rosy as one thinks. 

 

Pros: as mentioned above

Cons: 

1.  A parent must be present during the counselling and medical board.  Are you willing to OPEN up in front of your presence?

2.  The serviceman needs to continue life as per normal, i.e. the medical downgrading does NOT include IPPT - you still need to undergo the annual test and of course, the ICT cycle.

3.   Social stigma and pressure can be very unbearable.  Your superiors may shout A-gua, Faggot, Chee-by as it is the lingua franca in the army.

4.   Some overweight CQMS and Enciks may request for blow jobs....

 

Post NS:

You can almost kiss goodbye to government-related jobs and scholarships..potential employer may ask you why are you downgraded..blah blah blah..

 

**Don't think that 302 is an end to all means.  Yes you are not allowed to stay beyond 6 pm and unless you are living near to your army camp, travelling daily may be a waste of time.  Really, what is so hard about army training that you can't take..everybody does it...